The Top Ten 'My Favorite Murder' Episodes You Must Listen To

2025 iHeartPodcast Awards Live At SXSW

Photo: Getty Images North America

True Crime Comedy podcast "My Favorite Murder" recently reached an impressive milestone: its 500th episode.

Nearly 10 years after its debut, hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, continue to share the most compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners, covering cases involving infamous serial killers, mysterious cold cases, cults and so much more. If you're a true crime fan, this is a can't-miss podcast.

In celebration of the 500th episode of "My Favorite Murder," check out a list of the top ten most-listened to episodes of the show.

"18 - Investigateighteen Discovery"

Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Mary Vincent and the crimes of Franklin Delano Floyd.

"104 - Garden Party"

Karen and Georgia cover the case of Susan Kuhnhausen and the Order of the Solar Temple cult.

"105 - Proclensity"

Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Christa Worthington and the case of Typhoid Mary.

"186 - Sprankers!"

Karen and Georgia cover the obsessive case of Carl Tanzler and stories of people buried alive.

"190 - Lick The Clock"

Karen and Georgia cover the Radium Girls and the murder of Lisa Cihaski.

"203 - Live at the Fox Theatre in Atlanta"

Karen and Georgia cover the kidnapping of Barbara Mackle and the Barbie Bandits. With special guest Chuck Bryant.

"221 - Symbolic Violins"

Karen and Georgia cover the rescue of Baby Jessica and the deaths of Sid Vicious and Nancy Spungen.

"225 - It’s Jenga"

Karen and Georgia cover the life of Ida B. Wells and the Stonewall uprising.

"268 - All Stars of Seventh Grade"

Karen and Georgia cover the Poet of Wichita and Cocaine Bear.

"233 - Free Range Children"

Karen and Georgia cover the Zoot Suit Riots and the 1976 Chowchilla bus kidnapping.

"366 - High-Pitched Goodbye"

This week, Georgia tells the story of the Mirabal sisters, heroes of the Dominican Republic, and Karen covers Cleveland's infamous 1974 Ten Cent Beer Night.


Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content